Case files · est. 2026 Found andFailed

CASE 001 · Vine / TikTok

What happened to Vine?

Vine shut down because Twitter never gave it, or its stars, a way to earn money. Twitter bought the three-person app in October 2012, before launch. By January 2016, 200 million people watched Vine videos each month, yet Vine had no ad product. Twitter turned down its top creators in late 2015 and announced the shutdown on October 27, 2016.

CASE 001

Vine2012–2017

Shut down

TikTok won

Died: A candle in the rain, from our Vine episode. Won: Shooting a dance for a phone feed, from our Vine episode.

How Vine went

  1. Twitter buys Vine, a three-person company in New York, before the app has launched. The price was never disclosed; it was widely reported at about $30 million.

  2. Vine launches on iPhone: six-second videos that loop.

  3. Instagram adds 15-second video, five months after Vine's launch.

  4. Vine reports 40 million registered users.

  5. Vine says it serves more than 1.5 billion loops a day.

  6. About 18 of Vine's biggest creators ask for $1.2 million each to keep posting. The deal does not go through.

  7. Vine says over 200 million people watch Vine videos each month.

  8. Twitter announces it will shut Vine down.

  9. The Vine app is switched off.

  10. TikTok absorbs Musical.ly and goes live in the US.

  11. Vine co-founder Dom Hofmann launches Byte, which ends its first day as the No. 1 free iPhone app in the US.

  12. TikTok announces a $200 million creator fund, pledged to grow to $1 billion in the US over three years.

  13. Byte, sold in 2021 and renamed, is shut down.

The numbers

Reported price Twitter paid for Vine, 2012
about $30 million
Twitter's total revenue in 2012, so the deal was close to a tenth of it
$317 million
Loops played per day, 2015
1.5 billion
Monthly viewers, January 2016 (app, web and embeds)
200 million
Direct revenue: no ad product, no creator payments
$0
What 18 top creators asked for in 2015, $21.6 million in all
$1.2 million each
Twitter's market value on the day it announced the shutdown
$12.4 billion
Loops on Lele Pons's Vines, the most-watched person on Vine (2016)
8.57 billion

Who won with Vine's idea?

TikTok. ByteDance merged Musical.ly into TikTok and launched it in the US in August 2018, built on short, looping, full-screen video made by creators.

TikTok then did what Vine's stars had asked Twitter to do: pay creators. In July 2020 it announced a $200 million creator fund, pledged to reach $1 billion in the US over three years.

By September 2021 TikTok said it had 1 billion monthly users. Its parent ByteDance was valued at more than $300 billion in employee share buybacks in 2024 and 2025.

Questions about Vine

Why did Vine shut down?

Twitter never built a way for Vine or its creators to earn money from the app. Vine had no ad product and no creator payments. Its top creators left for YouTube and Instagram, and Twitter announced the shutdown on October 27, 2016.

How much did Twitter pay for Vine?

The price was never officially disclosed. It was widely reported at about $30 million, paid in October 2012 before Vine had launched.

How many people used Vine?

Vine had 40 million registered users by August 2013. In January 2016 it said over 200 million people watched Vine videos each month, counting the app, the web and embeds.

What did Vine's creators ask Twitter for?

In fall 2015, 18 of Vine's top creators asked for $1.2 million each, $21.6 million in total, to keep posting original videos. The deal did not go through.

Is TikTok the same as Vine?

No. TikTok is owned by ByteDance and grew out of Musical.ly, which it absorbed in 2018. It uses the format Vine made popular: short, looping, vertical video from creators.

Sources

Every figure on this page has at least two independent sources in our fact-check file. Figures with only one were left out.

  1. AllThingsD, Oct 9 2012
  2. Motley Fool, May 2017
  3. Wikipedia, Vine
  4. TechCrunch, Jan 22 2016
  5. TechCrunch May 2015
  6. MIT Technology Review, Oct 31 2022
  7. The Drum, Oct 28 2016
  8. Mic, Oct 29 2016
  9. Washington Post, Sep 28 2023
  10. Billboard
  11. TechCrunch, Oct 27 2016
  12. Variety, Oct 27 2016
  13. TechCrunch, Jan 23–24 2013
  14. CNN, Jun 20 2013
  15. TechCrunch, Jun 20 2013
  16. MarTech, Aug 2013
  17. Engadget, Aug 20 2013
  18. Adweek, Jan 26 2015
  19. TikTok Newsroom, Aug 2018
  20. Wikipedia, TikTok
  21. TechCrunch, Jan 24 2020
  22. Yahoo/Sensor Tower
  23. TIME
  24. TikTok Newsroom, Jul 2020
  25. Tubefilter, Jul 30 2020
  26. Wikipedia, Huddles
  27. TechCrunch, Oct 12 2021
  28. Digital Music News, Jan 27 2021
  29. Forbes, Oct 3 2013
  30. Inc.
  31. MarketCapHistory
  32. CompaniesMarketCap
  33. Guinness World Records
  34. Wikipedia, Lele Pons
  35. TikTok Newsroom, Sept 2021
  36. DemandSage 2026 estimate
  37. PYMNTS, Feb 25 2026
  38. Fortune, Nov 2024
  39. TechCrunch, Jan 23 2026