Case files · est. 2026 Found andFailed

SHORT CASE 01 · MoviePass / AMC Stubs A-List

Why did MoviePass fail?

MoviePass failed because it charged $9.95 a month for a movie a day and paid the theater full price for every ticket, when the average ticket in 2018 cost $9.11. By May 2018 it was spending $40 million a month more than it took in. The service shut down on September 14, 2019.

Found and Failed Short Case 1 thumbnail: MoviePass

SHORT CASE 01

How MoviePass went

  1. Helios and Matheson agrees to buy a majority stake in MoviePass. The same day, the price drops to $9.95 a month for one movie a day.

  2. Cinemark launches Movie Club: $8.99 a month for one ticket.

  3. MoviePass spends $40 million more than it takes in, and expects to be $45 million short in June.

  4. The company says it has more than three million paying subscribers.

  5. AMC launches Stubs A-List: $19.95 a month for up to three movies a week, IMAX and Dolby included.

  6. Helios files to raise up to $1.2 billion, then does a one-for-250 reverse stock split to keep its Nasdaq listing.

  7. Members' cards are declined at the box office. Helios borrows $5 million to switch the service back on.

  8. MoviePass drops a planned rise to $14.95. From mid-August, $9.95 buys three movies a month.

  9. Seven weeks in, A-List has more than 260,000 members.

  10. MoviePass reportedly has about 225,000 subscribers, down more than 90 percent from its peak.

  11. The MoviePass service shuts down.

  12. A-List passes 900,000 members, against a first-year target of 500,000.

  13. Helios files for Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

  14. Federal prosecutors charge former executives Ted Farnsworth and Mitch Lowe. Both later plead guilty, Lowe in 2024 and Farnsworth in 2025.

  15. AMC tells investors it has more than 1.1 million A-List members.

The numbers

MoviePass monthly price for a movie a day, from August 2017
$9.95
Average US movie ticket in 2018
$9.11
MoviePass paying subscribers, June 2018 (company figure)
more than 3 million
Cash spent beyond revenue in May 2018 alone
$40 million
Helios operating loss in the second quarter of 2018
$126.6 million
Helios and Matheson consolidated net loss for 2018
$329 million
AMC Stubs A-List launch price, up to three movies a week
$19.95
A-List members, Q2 2026
more than 1.1 million

Who won with MoviePass's idea?

AMC. In June 2018, while MoviePass was running out of cash, AMC launched Stubs A-List at $19.95 a month for up to three movies a week.

MoviePass had to buy every ticket at full price from theater chains. AMC was filling empty seats in its own buildings, and A-List charged about the price of two tickets a month, with a cap of three films a week.

Seven weeks in, A-List had more than 260,000 members. By late 2019 it had more than 900,000, against a first-year target of 500,000, and AMC told investors it believed the program was profitable.

In 2025 AMC raised the price to as much as $27.99 a month in New York and California, now for four movies a week. In 2026 it reported more than 1.1 million members, about one in five of its US visits.

Questions about MoviePass

Why did MoviePass fail?

It charged $9.95 a month for a movie a day and paid theaters full price for every ticket, when the average 2018 ticket cost $9.11. The more people used it, the more it lost.

How much money did MoviePass lose?

In May 2018 it spent $40 million more than it took in. Helios and Matheson, its parent company, lost $126.6 million from operations in the second quarter of 2018 and $329 million for the year.

When did MoviePass shut down?

The service shut down on September 14, 2019. Helios and Matheson filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy in January 2020.

How many subscribers did MoviePass have?

The company said it had more than three million paying subscribers in June 2018. By April 2019 it reportedly had about 225,000.

Did the FTC take action against MoviePass?

Yes. The FTC alleged that MoviePass invalidated the passwords of about 75,000 of its most active subscribers. The company and its executives settled in June 2021 without admitting or denying the allegations, and the order included no money for consumers.

Were MoviePass executives charged?

Federal prosecutors charged Ted Farnsworth and Mitch Lowe in 2022. Lowe pleaded guilty to conspiracy in September 2024, and Farnsworth pleaded guilty to securities fraud and conspiracy in January 2025.

Is MoviePass back?

Yes. Co-founder Stacy Spikes bought it back out of bankruptcy in 2021, and it relaunched in 2022 with credit plans of $10, $20 and $30 a month.

Sources

Every figure on this page has at least two independent sources in our fact-check file. Figures with only one were left out.

  1. S1 HMNY 8-K
  2. S2 TheWrap
  3. S3 TheWrap
  4. S4 Marketplace
  5. S6 Wikipedia
  6. S9 KSL/CNN
  7. S24 TechCrunch
  8. S25 NBC News
  9. S62 Cinemark IR
  10. S63 TheWrap
  11. S7 Slashfilm
  12. S8 Cord Cutters / Statista
  13. S43 AMC IR
  14. S44 THR
  15. S10 HMNY 10-Q
  16. S11 Benzinga
  17. S12 TechCrunch
  18. S13 ScreenCrush/Deadline
  19. S14 THR
  20. S15 CNBC
  21. S45 AMC IR
  22. S46 Subscription Insider
  23. S22 Deseret
  24. S23 Paste / Statista
  25. S51 AMC 8-K Q3 2019
  26. S52 THR
  27. S20 Variety
  28. S26 TheWrap
  29. S31 DOJ release 22-1191
  30. S32 NBC/CNBC
  31. S33 DOJ case page
  32. S34 Variety / S35 THR
  33. hollywoodreporter.com
  34. S36 CNN / S37 Deadline
  35. deadline.com
  36. S58 AMC Q2 2026 release
  37. S59 Investing.com transcript
  38. S18 Motley Fool
  39. fool.com
  40. S21 HMNY DEFA14A
  41. S53 AMC 8-K Q4 2019
  42. S56 Variety 2025
  43. S57 GameSpot
  44. S27 FTC complaint
  45. S28 Infosecurity / Complex
  46. S29 FTC release
  47. S30 CyberScoop
  48. S38 TheWrap
  49. S39 9to5Mac
  50. S40 NPR
  51. S41 Engadget